The Copy That Saved the Original

    The Copy That Saved the Original

    In 1820, forty-four years after it was signed in Philadelphia, the Declaration of Independence was already showing its age. The original manuscript had been treated roughly during the Revolutionary War and its aftermath, and the ink was beginning to fade. This physical decay prompted a project of preservation, led by then Secretary of State John Quincy Adams, the son of signer John Adams.

    The country was in a period of renewed patriotism following the War of 1812. This mood produced what printing historian John Bidwell has called “heroic engravings” of the document. Notable examples by John Binns and Benjamin Owen Tyler were more inspirational than accurate, incorporating facsimiles of the signatures but taking artistic liberties with the text. Adams, according to Bidwell, believed the American people deserved a version “untainted by demeaning publicity and arbitrary artistic interventions.”

    An Exacting Commission

    Adams first approached Benjamin Owen Tyler for the work, but found his proposed fee of $150 too high. He then turned to William J. Stone, an engraver who had worked in the same shop that printed Tyler’s version. Stone’s skill in banknote engraving made him the ideal candidate for a task that demanded absolute precision.

    It took Stone three years to complete the copperplate engraving. The exact method he used is still a matter of some debate. While some have suggested a wet-ink transfer process, a close examination by specialist Seth Kaller comparing the original manuscript to Stone’s work suggests tracing was the more likely technique. More than a dozen small differences support this, including a decorative 45-degree line through the capital ‘T’ at the top of the Stone print that does not appear on the original. This level of forensic detail points away from a riskier wet process.

    By April 1823, the plate was finished. The State Department authorized a run of 200 copies to be printed on vellum. John Quincy Adams noted in his diary in October 1822 that while the signatures were done, Stone still had “much to labour” on the Declaration itself.

    Gallery

    A Declaration for Posterity

    Though the credit line on the engraving is dated July 4, 1823, distribution of the 201 vellum copies began in June 1824. A Congressional resolution on May 26 directed that the facsimiles be given out to honor the upcoming 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. Two copies each went to President James Monroe, the Vice-President, former President James Madison, and the three surviving signers: Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and Charles Carroll of Carrollton. Twenty copies were allocated for Congress, and two were presented to the Marquis de Lafayette. One of Lafayette's copies was later sold at Christie's in 1985.

    While Adams sought to create a definitive, apolitical record, a few copies may have served his own ambitions. During the hotly contested 1824 Presidential election, which was ultimately decided in the House of Representatives, Adams gave inscribed copies to Joshua Prideaux and Thomas Emory. Both were electors for Maryland, a state Adams found difficult to win. As historian Catherine Nicholson noted, one “can only speculate if the Stone engravings that Adams presented to influential politicians… had any impact on the presidential electoral vote.”

    The project ultimately secured the visual identity of America's founding document. William Stone’s copperplate became the source for all subsequent reproductions, including an 1833 edition by Peter Force for his history of the United States. Today, it is estimated that about a quarter of the original 201 Stone engravings survive, with a recent census counting 52 known copies. Of those, 27 are in institutional collections. With at least nine others held by a private collector who plans to donate them, approximately twelve remain in private hands.

    Read more about collecting here.